Saturday, January 11, 2014

Need to replace existing multi-point tax system with simplified single-point tax system



Much has been said, debated and discussed about the idea of replacing existing tax regime of multiple tax points – Income Tax, Wealth Tax, Excise Tax, Sales Tax – VAT, Octori, Local Body Tax, etc with just one tax point system of Goods and Services Tax or Banking Transaction Tax.

I believe at 67, the country has matured to initiate a debate on how effective the existing taxation system has been and do a cost-benefit analysis.

To clarify, a Pune-based think-tank –Aarthkranti - has made a detailed presentation on their proposal of introducing Banking Transaction Tax. Among many suggestions, they propose banning currency notes over Rs. 50, curtail legal protection for cash transactions of over Rs. 2000, tax each receipt in bank account at rate of 2% as Banking Transaction Tax. It is their belief that such tax regime would curtail corruption, reduce tax collection cost and boost revenues.

Unfortunately, the media in all its fairness, started badgering their favourite punch-bag – BJP – for even thinking of considering this proposal (skipping the fact that this is being considered along with many other tax structure models – whether media skipped by oversight or design; I leave it to their wisdom and truthfulness). Editorial in ‘Business Standard’ ‘declared’ it ‘BJPs strange brainwave’, ‘poorly thought out’ and ‘radical plan’! So much for just receiving the proposal from citizens of this country and considering it without any bias! [http://www.business-standard.com/article/opinion/bjp-s-strange-brainwave-114010901238_1.html]

To my knowledge, replacing multiple-tax system with simplified version of either one indirect tax called GST or via Banking Transactions has been in public discussion since last eleven years (or may be more). A few years back one of the leading Mumbai based CA firm published it in its annual Finance Budget Analysis a similar suggestion. These proposals have been under consideration of many political parties and citizen think-tanks alike.

Rate of tax, currency denomination in circulation, basic exemption limit for cash transactions, exemption to banking transactions like loans, fixed deposits, demand-drafts, NPA-Stressed-Assets resolutions, etc can be simplified / details-modalities worked out and all such details / suggestions are still subject to feedback from citizens. It has been parliamentary tradition to put new legislations of larger public interest and implication in public domain in advance for feedback from citizens – recent two examples being citizen feedback for Lokpal Bill and Direct Tax Code.

I do not find anything wrong in remaining open to out-of-box suggestions. Point is government need not rush through every idea popped-up like it did in case of Aadhar project - a massive failure with high security risk and expense burden of over Rs. 1 lac crore, yet covering less than half of our population, banking linkages still not fully established and prone to money leaks.

The present Income Tax has outlived its utility. The cost incurred under the Income Tax system - direct cost: staff employed by Income Tax department, support infrastructure, judicial forums, legal teams, loss of interest on account of litigation delays (my dear friend has suggested RTI to get precise cost figure incurred at government end which we would certainly pursue, though I am sceptical whether accurate data would be shared in time detailing all the costs discussed here) and indirect cost: at the end of tax payers like professional CA & lawyer costs, litigation costs, loss of interest on account of refund and litigations, etc far outweigh the benefit of total direct tax collected. Of approximately 17 crore people who are above poverty line, there are only approximately 3 crore assessee's. Of these 3 crore, the active assessee's are still lesser who regularly file their return of income. This small group of tax payers cannot rationally be made to bear burden of entire 120 crore population needs. Certainly, there is a need for tax regime but the present system is greatly flawed.

On Indirect Tax front - Excise and Service Tax - the staff employed is disproportionately lower. The number of business - both under organised and unorganised sector spread across the nation - are far more than the department can handle. Besides, there are constant technological advancements and changes in business models. The indirect taxes departments have just not been able to keep up with the business needs or understanding of the same. This has resulted in massive losses on indirect tax front – both in terms of loss of revenue and revenue tied up in litigations. The recent service tax amnesty scheme is the case in point. The rate at which new services where bought under service tax net, the department just could not keep up with the pace, as it grossly lacked infrastructure and failed to understand how service industry operates. I doubt that no substantial recover could have been made inspite of this amnesty scheme.

In such situations, few honest who pay taxes in time and in-full are put to unreasonable cash-flow disadvantage vis-a-vis the routine defaulters - mostly due to lack of departmental vigilance and capabilities. Thus, again on indirect tax front too, it demands a cost-benefit analysis for continuing with existing model.

In the end, if cost of collection for the nation (both at government and tax-payers end) exceed the benefits or net benefit is only marginal, then it can only mean additional tax burden on existing small group of tax payers..!!

More ideas are welcomed. Critical analyses with alternate solutions are welcomed too.

Saturday, September 28, 2013

'Right to Reject' and 'Compulsory Voting' - Awesome Couple in any Democracy..!!



SC has ruled on 'Right to Reject' (RTR) which translated in layman's language is ‘None of the above’ (NOTA) option in election process. From next election onwards the voters (those who that that pain to get out of their homes on the holiday called Election Day – only to vote) there will be one more option added on the voting machine at the end called ‘None of the Above’

Fortunately the Honourable Judges did not go further to change the outcome of the election process which could have led straight to anarchy. Hence, in that sense the 'Right to Reject' or 'None of the above' option currently remains a tokenism. Which means NOTA will only remain a button on the electronic voting machines eventually to be counted and ignored without influencing the electoral results. Though, it will surely make a huge psychological impact on the political class if NOTA votes exceed the votes for winning candidate in any constituency.

The original demand of RTR/NOTA was that if in any constituency the NOTA votes are higher than winning candidate, there would be re-election in that constituency. The logic being we do not want to elect corrupt or criminals to governing office.

Eventually, suppose, if we get that option, from where a new person would get elected unless one of us wishes to leave his / her comforts behind and serve nation.

So the solution lies in the problem itself. Governance. We have to be IN the system to CHANGE the system. Only those people who are responsible for execution of duties can bring the change. Hence, the only and lasting solution is fresh people entering governing institutions - get elected as leader / get selected as bureaucrat - and remain non-corrupt!

If we have waited for so long then why not wait till next elections or next IAS exams!

Empowered 'Right to Reject' which can enforce re-election, if enforced without 'Compulsory Voting' will lead to anarchy and distance the already disenchanted youth from the most noble patriotic activity of serving the nation.

Meanwhile, in absence of Compulsory Voting, the winning candidate has to concentrate only on about 8% to 15% of the population in his constituency.

Say for example, in any constituency, there are 120 people and of them 20 are below 18 years. From the rest, a large number of eligible citizens are not registered as voters. And balance who are registered as voters, only about 50% of them turn-up for voting. Hence, if any candidate concentrates only on certain religious, linguistic or caste-based community, he is more likely to win.

This apathy of citizens to not get registered as voter or turn-up at the polling booth on the Election Day is the primary problem for the pathological apathy of MP / MLA / Municipal Corporator towards citizens. The elected representative already knows that he is able to win even when over 80% of the population did not vote in his favour. He is even confident that he would get re-elected till he concentrates and nurtures this religious, linguistic or caste-based community with tokenism of food-booze parties, festival sponsorships and save them during law violations.

What if all 100% of eligible citizens of that constituency get registered as voters? What if all 100% eligible citizens come out and exercise their voting right? Will these political candidates win so easily? Will the leaders now only concentrate on religion, language or caste line or will these lines vanish if 100% eligible citizens come out to vote?

In who’s hand is this power to change this equation?

It is highly unfortunate that people have grown so disenchanted from electoral politics and have lost complete hope. It is highly unfortunate because there is no hope lost. In fact the nation is bright, sunny and smiling. It is the people who have closed their eyes and complaining of darkness.

The demand for ‘Compulsory Voting’ stems precisely because people shut their eyes and complain of darkness – loss of faith in electoral democracy.

For many this ‘Right to Reject’ or ‘None of the Above’ option seems the only solution to the political problems. This is their misconception. The anger against the present lot of politicians is justified but it is being misplaced entirely on to electoral process. Rather our own fellow brothers, sisters and friends are to share the blame as they enjoy the day off on Election Day and add to the politician’s complacency.

Both 'Right to Reject' and 'Compulsory Voting' can co-exist only together. One without other will only shift and change nature of problems.

If all 100% come out for vote, there is no specific community to appease. The only community to appease is the voters and in this case it would be all voters. This will make the elected representatives to work for all. The divisive politics would surely be minimised if not end immediately.

Join Politics..!!
Join Bureaucracy.!!
Get Registered..!!
Go Vote..!!
Strengthen Democracy - Lasting Solution - No Shortcut..!!

Saturday, September 21, 2013

Dear PM Manmohan Singh: Sell bullshit only if you are prepared to eat it back

Dear Prime Minister (PM) Manmohan Singh @PMOIndia;
Home Minister (HM) Sushil Shinde @MediaMHA; and
Defence Minister (DM) A K Anthony:

It is beyond ridiculous to believe that Hon'ble Former Army Chief V K Singh can topple an elected J&K Govt with budget of Rs. 8 cr.

The IB has been entrusted responsibility of monitoring entire Delhi area. It reports directly to PM & HM.

Why no report on fatal IB failure to detect alleged bugging, alleged call interception & alleged coup in Delhi.

Is this Govt so lame & impotent that it cannot ensure even basic surveillance in capital.

Please show which democracy of comparable size has been seen in recent past having public show down with its Army Chief.

Are PM & DM so very incompetent that they cannot even manage an amicable settlement with the Forces to sort differences in private.

Please also answer which chief initiated TSD? Who was DM then? Which party Ruled?

Is it possible to buy 'off-air call interceptors' in India so freely when no one manufactures them in India & their imports regulated and monitored by IB?

What action taken on Army Chief V K Singh's report to you on lack of defence preparedness?

If the matter was so serious WAS PM, HM, DM & establishment SLEEPING?

Sell bullshit only if you are prepared to eat it back.


Sincerely,

Ajay Dave

Friday, August 30, 2013

Bombing for Humanity..!!

The Rhetoric:

"Obama sought to win over a war-weary American public on Wednesday evening by saying intervention in Syria, where more than 100,000 people have been killed in 2 1/2 years of civil war, would serve U.S. national security interests."


"The United States, Britain and France say they can act with or without a U.N. Security Council resolution"

 
-Reuters report [http://in.reuters.com/article/2013/08/29/syria-crisis-idINDEE97S0CM20130829]


The Real:

I know what is happening there in Syria. Even I want Assad gone.

The pertinent question is whether the strategy of bombing entire nation just like Afghanistan or Iraq or Yugoslavia and host of other nations in last 2 decades is right and appropriate. Writing is on the wall.. if history is to be ignored, then we are better off living in Mars and Venus than on this planet.

Certainly, defence and pharmaceutical sectors contribute significantly to US GDP. Coincidently, they are the first direct beneficiaries of any war..!! Again, these invaded nations also happen to be resource rich but that's a strict no-no in media spin.

And I am in no mood to attribute child like innocence to US that it was caught by surprise. The issues in Syria are too well known since its independence from France and latter succession from UAF/Egypt. And last decade was too well documented. This so called peace-dove coalition led by US should have regulated Arms and Chemical sales to the country. The biggest beneficiaries yet again have been US and Russia alike in the arms and chemicals sale to Syrian government and extremists rebels alike.

The day Assad won with 97.6% votes, that was the day when alarm bells should have rung. Also, the extremist religious terror groups have become more active in Middle East (ME) and former soviet nations. A concerted effort led by UN should have started and been seen to be at work.

Unfortunately, again US led coalition has reduced UN only for photo-ops for celebrity peace ambassadors. But then US was also too busy bombing Afganistan and then Iraq and other nations intermittently.

No one is asking or expecting US to become custodian of world peace. But its history of invasions is too well known. Its straight-forward self-serving. Humanity is last on the list of its purpose and first on the media briefing list.

Look at Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Egypt (though no ground military action there, but certainly civil unrest was in part sponsored and supported by US led coalition).. More people have died during and after the military intervention than by former dictators or extremists.

Every nation which US has invaded in last 20 years has suffered in terms of humanity. There is no political stability, no economic stability, masses suffering massive malnutrition deaths.. As always, there will be massive displacement of people.. Refugee's will keep suffering and try to infiltrate into other nations to live but will keep getting caught and prosecuted for being aliens..!! And there is no foreseeable stability in sight for these invaded nations.


Assad may have had many human rights violations to his credit. But there is no denying that many of the former soviet nations are today also victims of extremist-islamic terror groups. Syria, Chechnya, Yugosalvia, Russia. It has spread even to China. These extremists groups are either linked to Al-queda or draw moral ideology / inspiration from Al-queda. The recent alledged chemical attack in Syria should be investigated with reference to activities of these extremist groups also.

We have been fed the same human rights and weapons of mass destruction story over and over again before every invasion. Look at Afghanistan. The Hamid Karzai government is now being forced by the same USA to strike a deal with Taliban-Al-Queda extremists groups against which USA forced it self to go on a war after promoting them in 70's and 80's to keep check on USSR. The extremist violance is on rise in Iraq.

The same is the case in Egypt. Former president Hossine Mubarak may have violated human rights to keep himself in power and also loot wealth of his own nation. But, Egypt never exported terror. The terror groups were kept in check. Post Tahrir-square / Arab spring, the main mediator and peace broker of Middle East (ME) Mubarak was overthrown and was replaced by Muslim Brotherhood extremists. Now was USA so naive to not know who is going to replace the Mubarak. Was there no intel on it. Ofcourse, it is a different matter that Mubarak outlived his utility for USA. Yasser Arafat of Palastine and Gaddafi of Libya gone to graves and military apparatus firmly in place in Iraq, there was no need for a ME peace-broker. No bonhomie required at Camp David to pacify Arafats and Gaddafi's.

Wars and invasions in last two decades have made world more unsafe and coincidently it is the same coalition which has led the wars and invasions. It begs a larger question. Is there no mechanism or apparatus in place in UN to discuss the matters? Can UN not resolve the conflicts including leading a war, if required? Or is it that UN supremacy is being systematically undermined by a certain group / block / coalition!

History is witness that damage and enduring pain it has inflicted on people of war zones far exceed the perceived projected benefits.


The nations with localised terror groups / dictators have been converted in to full-fledged terror exporting nations. Now these newly-converted-terror-exporting-rogue-nations have become everybody's business. There you go. Its now a world headache and every nation will have to contribute its part to keep world 'safer'.


We need to grow-up to find solutions better than stone-age / medieval approach of thrashing and bashing nations left, right and centre for acts of few rogue politicians. Nations have been destroyed, ordinary people, women, children are still suffering the damage caused in invaded nations in last two decades.


If Russia and China are perceived to be funding and supplying arms to Syria, then interests of US is also too well known - the benefits the war brings to its defence and pharma sectors. Besides, Syria being, so very surprising coincidently, oil rich nation..!!


And no one is talking Dafur or Sudan or Ghana as US and China have already marked their territories there in diamond and gold rich regions. No one is even bothered for the dark continent which employs child soldiers in thousands or even millions.

But, its got to be Syria. Irrespective whether UN Chemical inspectors find any wrong doing on part of incumbent government or not. Its got to get bombed for its physical proximity to Iran, Russia and China and most importantly its Oil. Its all geo-political power assertion and business gains for these so-called self-proclaimed saviours of humanity.


The whole approach is wrong. It is just wrong. I do not believe the media spin which US successfully manages to create and loyal media which propagates it world over.

What bigger proof does anyone need then the History itself - just check the past record of invaded nations in last 2 decades and conclude whether they are better-off or worst-off.

What really perplexes me is that collective intelligence of 7 billion people cannot even think of a better strategy, a better option.

In that case, clothes and gadgets apart, we are still living in stone-age.

Monday, June 17, 2013

Rise of Rupee Decline..!!



This has been my conclusion and observation of India’s Economic Policy and the consequential decline in Rupee value:

A brief related history, just for the record, is that though Manmohan Singh (MMS) presented the overrated 1992 budged which was hailed as saviour of India and secured economic-independence; it was Dr. Subramanian Swamy who actually saved Indian economy. During Gulf War (Aug 1990 to Feb 1991), US was facing one hardship – a refuelling base. We had already run a phenomenal bankruptcy inducing deficit. At that time Dr. Swamy convinced then PM Chandrashekhar to briefly change India’s foreign policy – back then India did not allow armed foreign missions any landing or refuelling base in India and voting in favour of US Gulf War action – a departure from non-aligned-movement principles. Dr. Swamy negotiated a deal with US securing $ 2-billion no-conditions-attached loan from IMF in exchange for allowing US aircrafts to land in Bombay for refuelling and voting in favour of resolution. That saved India in first place. Ensuing negotiations in Davos and 1992 budget is well known.  [Please read the note below my blog article.]

For long we have been following the model of deficit financing. The problem is not the model or the method adopted but the deficit in vision and ground action.

For that genesis of the policy, policy makers need to be checked. Most planning commission members, finance ministry bureaucrats, RBI Officers and MMS himself subscribe to superficial concept that stabilizing rupee is key to fiscal management including inflation. Incidentally, most of them share same brainwashing background - IMF and WB stints where developing economy nominees are impressed up on to keep currency stable. This, they impress, is easily achieve by FII and FDI foreign-exchange-currency (forex) inflows.

I will come back on FDI latter. But the easiest way out, undisputedly, is FII inflows. It is nothing but 'Hot Money'. Every sane economist and his dog will understand that.

Herein lies the problem. One of the main causes - the gap between imports and exports, with imports dominating, leads to rupee depreciation which upsets fiscal deficit as most developing nations are net importing countries and it adds inflationary pressure.

The correct and harder way to address this 'net import gap situation' is to strengthen manufacturing and services export sector. This in medium to long term would ensure a rise in baseline of net forex inflows, bringing down reliance on forex inflows from FII and FDI. Infact, there could be a situation achieved where a range bound appreciation or depreciation would be healthy for economy. This can only and only be achieved only by country investing in road, rail, port, communication, water supply, storage / warehousing and power infrastructure.

Even after the overrated 1992 budget, the country remained clue-less till year 2000. Between 2000 and 2004 huge number of road, rail, port, SEZ, storage and power projects were started. Communication including internet penetration was well achieved. Dedicated rail and sea freight corridor reduced the assets / goods delivery time and the consequential reduction in demurrage charges entities had suffer. Road infrastructure was started with intention to again reduce the movement time and reduce the transport / fuel costs. The ten-lane north-south-east-west corridor and the 8-lane golden quadrilateral progressed at 11.5 kms per day! River interlinking study was re-initiated. SEZ and power projects were started with all good intentions. Point is all this was with focus to create a 'Real' economic growth - an environment conducive to propel manufacturing and services export growth. Though it happened along with related corruption, the net real benefit gave a stable boost to the economy with forex reserves at record high since independence.

Post 2004, all infrastructure projects came to stand still and there was sudden influx of FII money. Large funds flew-in via P-Note route. Markets – both stocks and bullion – scaled record heights, which was very predictably not sustainable even without 2008 global crises. Sustainable or not, as per prudent and rational economic assessment, it is generally contrary - there is flight of money outwards when infra spend touches near zero in any country.

Consequently and again repeating – predictably, has lead to sustained and gradual withdrawal of FII money leading to continuous rupee depreciation. Coupled with the recent downward trend in IIP growth rate (though govt. keeps revising the past data by blaming error on some random junior officers).

Blaming Vodafone tax change (which was step in right direction and UK also followed the suit in charging Vodafone in other tax evasion case there) and coalition alliance partners does not change the ground reality that there has been almost a decade of absence in net infra spend.

My conclusion holds good as there is atleast one state government i.e Gujarat, which has invested huge money in last decade in creating infrastructure and arranging conducive industrial environment, that it beats national averages on most economic parameters.

Coming to FDI, it is just one of the methods to boost investments in manufacturing and services sector. Under fair investment environment, both domestic and international investors / entrepreneurs would grab every opportunity to join 'real growth' story. But as discussed above, there has been downward growth in real economy. Then how come FDI is attracted? That only indicates, FDI entities are given massive unreasonable concession to invest in India further hurting domestic manufacturing and services sector as it gives unfair advantage to FDI entities. Which again brings me back to my conclusion that FDI is invited at regular intervals giving unfair benefits to them only to ensure forex inflow to stabilise rupee in short term.

Under-achievement in creating adequate infrastructure, rampant corruption in every government ventures (adventures), gross mismanagement of economy, doling out sops/money via MNERGA, Direct Cash Transfer, Loan Waivers, Food Security Bill, et al are all unproductive govt spends and consistent devaluation of rupee (which greatly impacts India as it is net importing country), has had a very negative impact at grassroot level - spiralling production and labour costs. The most immediate impact and victim is domestic industries – this is more of a policy deficit than industry cyclical phenomenon or on account of global-crisis .

To my mind, Rupee was doomed in 2004 itself when by December that year, the road-layout (NS-EW Corridor & Golden Quadrilateral) progress dropped to 11 kms per year from 11 kms per day! Rest is history - the decline in infra and illogical rise in stock & bullion markets.

To over-simplify, the short-term funds ie. the annual revenue generated was used-up for long-term purposes like loan-waiver, defence equipment purchases, scam-outflows, parking in offshore accounts, etc. And funds raised for long-term projects purposes like infrastructure projects, etc where used-up for short-term purposes like subsidies, MNREGA, cash transfers, 5th-6th pay-commission salary rise, etc. Result is a mismatched messed-up economy, struggling to stay afloat by committing a hara-kiri of sorts.

Ofcourse, in today’s world there are exotic monetary products to manage economy like subscribing to T-Bills of US and other countries, rate-cuts, reducing gold-imports, CRR, surrogate financing, blah blah, etc.. all of which can be justified or blamed…. but the raw fact remains that only export of goods and services ensure steady forex flows and reduce reliance on these fancy-named exotic fiscal management measures.


PS: I am reproducing extract from ‘My friend turned foe turned friend: Chandrashekhar’ by Dr. Subramanian Swamy (Chapter V):

When we first met as a government in November 1991, Chandrasekhar told the cabinet that there was a great economic crisis particularly in petroleum and foreign exchange looming. After some discussion, it was decided by the PM that I should, for controlling the crisis, explore some informal steps to obtain crude oil on barter i.e., in exchange of sugar, or engineering goods, and also get $ 2 billion (Rs.6000 crores) IMF loans (and without conditions). That is, the PM wanted me to act as Finance Minister as well! Chandrasekhar had denied me the Finance Ministership when the Cabinet was formed because, he told me my free market philosophy would “embarrass” his “socialist” image. But the real reason was (in my opinion) I, as Finance Minister, would go after the Swiss bank accounts of politicians, and as a consequence, many political leaders would go to jail. (There is Rs.3,20,000 crores deposited illegally by Indians in Swiss banks). Therefore when the Cabinet was being formed, there was near hysteria at the prospect of my becoming Finance Minister. Chandrasekhar was bombarded by these frightened friends, saying “please bring the devil as Finance Minister, but not Swamy”.

When the Cabinet meeting was over, Chandrasekhar asked me to come with him to the airport (he was going to Varanasi). In the car, sitting next to him I taunted him: “you denied me the Finance Minister, and now you want me to do the work of the Finance Minister as well?” “Arre Baba!” he exclaimed in Hindi, the economy is on verge of collapse and you can only think of your grievance”. “‘Why should I do this task?” I persisted. After all, Commerce and Law, was my portfolio, and therefore why should I have to work for another Minister? “Listen” said Chandrasekhar “No one else in the Cabinet has your contacts abroad, in USA, Israel, China etc., so use it for the nation’s sake”.

We sat quietly till the car reached the Special VVIP airport, and out to the tarmac where the IAF Boeing reserved for the PM was parked. As he climbed the stair case to alight the plane, I told him when he returned, I would have a proposal on how to tackle the financial crisis. “To hell with the Finance Ministership” I said to myself. “CCPA membership is more prestigious”.

The foreign exchange crisis had been caused by the large number of short term loans (3 -5 years repayment) taken from Europe by the Rajiv Gandhi government (1985-89) mostly to pay for defence equipment purchases abroad. These loans became due for repayment during V.P.Singh’s tenure as PM (who as finance Minister sanctioned it) but he slept over it. So when we came to power it coincided with non-payment, plotting to declare India as a defaulter or bankrupt. It was a Mexican type situation. We needed $ 2 billion to tide over this, and save our reputation. We could, like Mexico, straight away have applied to the IMF for a “crisis loan”, but then the IMF would have strapped us, like Mexico, with humiliating conditions. When I spoke to Rajiv Gandhi about this crisis, after returning from the airport, he said flatly that the Congress party would not support any Mexican type conditionality. So our government was in a fix: “No conditions, No loan from IMF; no loan, no economy!”

But I knew of one possible escape route. The IMF is dominated by the Americans, who control 87 percent of the voting power in the Executive Board of the IMF. Despite popular impressions to the contrary, Americans are very simple people if you have a deal with them on a give and take basis. If you want something from an American, offer him something in return which he needs. Then he will respond fully. Americans in the past were irritated with us because we took their aid, and yet voted against them in the UN. Americans are straight forward, contractual minded people, whereas we are highly moralistic people who do not like to reveal our mind. Americans are much like me in character: blunt and open in thought, but a typical Indian is more like Narasimha Rao: soft in words, but covert in action. So when Chandrasekhar returned to Delhi, I received him at the airport, and told him of Rajiv Gandhi’s refusal to support an IMF conditions-prone loan. I then told him: “There is one way out. Ask the Americans to help. They will help, if you offer them something in return”. “What can be possibly given them that they do not have already?” asked Chandrasekhar. I had no answer. I just kept quiet. Chandrasekhar said “We are running out of time. Think of something”.

Soon after sometime, the opportunity came. The US Ambassador came to my Commerce Ministry office to tell me that the US was planning to support a UN declaration of war on Iraq, and US will conduct the operations. He said that the Indian government should support the war effort of the US.

With IMF on my mind, I asked the Ambassador: “What will India get by doing so?” The Ambassador was taken back. He said it was a moral imperative for the world, since Kuwait had been crushed by Iraq’s invasion. I laughed at the US ambassador. I told him “Listen Excellency, ten years in the US as a student and as a professor has made me more American than you. You keep your moral imperative, but give me a deal”. I explained our problem to him. He was very sympathetic. As I expected, he immediately responded. Thereafter President Bush and Chandrasekhar were in touch with each other. The $ 2 billion arrived without any conditions! We, of course allowed the US to refuel their planes flying in from Philiphines to Saudi Arabia. Nowhere will it be recorded as a “deal”, but the truth is this. In the history of the IMF, such a large loan has never been given without conditions. Ours was the exception.
(Source: www.wp.janataparty.org/?p=205)

[Reason for sharing this 1990 incident as narrated by Dr. Swamy is to prove that we need leaders who can raise above petty politics and work for the country. Solutions are always there, we need will and courage to implement them.]